Jump to content

Community:GTA IV Gripes: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
Line 30: Line 30:
{{Gripe}}Minor clothing items are removed during some cut scenes and missions. (glasses, hats)
{{Gripe}}Minor clothing items are removed during some cut scenes and missions. (glasses, hats)
:{{Rebut}}This can be easily explained by Niko having ''manners''... i.e. he would remove his hat or glasses before speaking with someone.
:{{Rebut}}This can be easily explained by Niko having ''manners''... i.e. he would remove his hat or glasses before speaking with someone.
::{{Gripe}} Still affects realism though because the items just disappear into thin air.


{{Gripe}}Cars explode for the stupidest and unrealistic reasons, i.e. shooting the window of a car, shooting the roof.
{{Gripe}}Cars explode for the stupidest and unrealistic reasons, i.e. shooting the window of a car, shooting the roof.
Line 55: Line 56:
{{Gripe}}Stealth kills as in San Andreas are no longer possible.
{{Gripe}}Stealth kills as in San Andreas are no longer possible.
:{{Rebut}}You can perform a stealth kill during Final Interview and walk out without a wanted level.
:{{Rebut}}You can perform a stealth kill during Final Interview and walk out without a wanted level.
::{{Gripe}}But on outside missions, you can't. It's straying away realism because it did'nt even have the silenced pistol.
::{{Gripe}}But on outside missions, you can't. It's straying away realism because it didn't even have the silenced pistol.
:::{{Gripe}} In final interview you cannot perform a stealth kill. Even if you use the knife to kill Goldberg, the receptionist still runs in screaming, and a 3 star wanted level is in place.  


{{Gripe}}Cops somehow manage to stay alive even after multiple gunshots, and their weapons do more damage to the player.
{{Gripe}}Cops somehow manage to stay alive even after multiple gunshots, and their weapons do more damage to the player.
Line 109: Line 111:
{{Gripe}}You can longer respond to random comments either positively or negatively.
{{Gripe}}You can longer respond to random comments either positively or negatively.
:{{Rebut}}  That was a minor feature, and its removal doesn't affect the game very much.
:{{Rebut}}  That was a minor feature, and its removal doesn't affect the game very much.
::{{Gripe}} It is still one more thing that detracts from the game's attempt at realism. And it has a fairly big impact on the free roam part of the game.


{{Gripe}}You must keep your 'friends' happy to retain their special perks. It would have been preferable to unlock their abilities once and then be left to the player to decide whether they wish to continue the 'friendship'.
{{Gripe}}You must keep your 'friends' happy to retain their special perks. It would have been preferable to unlock their abilities once and then be left to the player to decide whether they wish to continue the 'friendship'.
:{{Rebut}} Don't you have to keep your friends happy in real life?
:{{Rebut}} Don't you have to keep your friends happy in real life?
::{{Gripe}} But you don't drive them all over town like a soccer mom, especially if you are one of the most in demand hitmen in the city. Roman owns a car service business, yet needs to be picked up and dropped off everytime he wants to do anything. The friends feature becomes irritating because it lacks realism.
::{{Gripe}} But you don't drive them all over town like a soccer mom, especially if you are one of the most in demand hit men in the city. Roman owns a car service business, yet needs to be picked up and dropped off every time he wants to do anything. The friends feature becomes irritating because it lacks realism.


{{Gripe}}Street Gang-Banging and generally street gang-related missions have been dramatically reduced, means, no point in shooting other gang members.
{{Gripe}}Street Gang-Banging and generally street gang-related missions have been dramatically reduced, means, no point in shooting other gang members.
Line 120: Line 123:
{{Gripe}}Only 9 street races available and difficult to access them through the phone system.
{{Gripe}}Only 9 street races available and difficult to access them through the phone system.
:{{Rebut}}GTA is not exactly a 'racing game'. The racing missions are practically just mini games, save for when they affect the storyline.
:{{Rebut}}GTA is not exactly a 'racing game'. The racing missions are practically just mini games, save for when they affect the storyline.
::{{Gripe}} Racing is one of the few things left to do once the storyline has been completed.


{{Gripe}}No special races that unlock special cars (like Destruction Derby).
{{Gripe}}No special races that unlock special cars (like Destruction Derby).
Line 136: Line 140:
:{{Rebut}} there are also, more or less, no aircrafts to jump out of at high altitudes.
:{{Rebut}} there are also, more or less, no aircrafts to jump out of at high altitudes.
::{{Rebut}}Plus the s'shoot' was quite boring to use anways.
::{{Rebut}}Plus the s'shoot' was quite boring to use anways.
:::{{Gripe}}Yet another component that affects the longevity of this game. The fact that Niko can't base jump into Star Junction and start shooting up the area is just another shortcoming of IV in terms of action. 


{{Gripe}}Cops manage to shoot your tires out, even if you're going 100mph.
{{Gripe}}Cops manage to shoot your tires out, even if you're going 100mph.
Line 146: Line 151:
{{Gripe}}You can't order cars from Stevie's garage once the text message missions he gives you are completed.
{{Gripe}}You can't order cars from Stevie's garage once the text message missions he gives you are completed.
:{{Rebut}} That function was specifically for the aforementioned missions.
:{{Rebut}} That function was specifically for the aforementioned missions.
::{{Gripe}}A useless set of missions at that. You can't access Stevie's Garage after completing the missions, and there is no use for the money you made from the missions. Just another bland effort from GTA IV.


{{Gripe}}Combat is unrealistic and hard to attack people. You'll have to use weapons to kill them instead (not meleé ones).
{{Gripe}}Combat is unrealistic and hard to attack people. You'll have to use weapons to kill them instead (not meleé ones).
Line 170: Line 176:
{{Gripe}}The majority of the good cheats are gone (like chaos, citizens with weapons, cars fly away with hits etc etc etc).
{{Gripe}}The majority of the good cheats are gone (like chaos, citizens with weapons, cars fly away with hits etc etc etc).
:{{Rebut}}Rockstar never releases cheats they are found by the players most likely the same cheats are there, they just haven't been found yet.
:{{Rebut}}Rockstar never releases cheats they are found by the players most likely the same cheats are there, they just haven't been found yet.
::{{Gripe}}The range of cheats is another source of disappointment. There is no more to be found.


{{Gripe}}There are only 2 pairs of glasses in the whole game, and both of them are ugly.
{{Gripe}}There are only 2 pairs of glasses in the whole game, and both of them are ugly.
Line 175: Line 182:
::{{Gripe}}They are. Both are big "owl" style glasses from the 90s. No actual sunglasses or anything.
::{{Gripe}}They are. Both are big "owl" style glasses from the 90s. No actual sunglasses or anything.
:::{{Rebut}}I don't think that R* made this game just for the sake of different clothings you can buy for Niko.
:::{{Rebut}}I don't think that R* made this game just for the sake of different clothings you can buy for Niko.
:::{{Gripe}} Badly affects the realism though. 2 pairs of sunglasses in the whole of Liberty City? Geez...gritty realism if ever I've seen it.


{{Gripe}}Whenever you crash you go flying out of the windsheild.
{{Gripe}}Whenever you crash you go flying out of the windsheild.
Line 189: Line 198:
{{Gripe}}There is no [[Tank]] in this game, nor are there airplanes.
{{Gripe}}There is no [[Tank]] in this game, nor are there airplanes.
:{{Rebut}}Tanks would be unrealistic, as the armed forces would not send a tank into New York City after a single man.  Airplanes would also be unrealistic because air-travel around New York City is extremely restricted, plus there's really not enough area to ''need'' air-travel.
:{{Rebut}}Tanks would be unrealistic, as the armed forces would not send a tank into New York City after a single man.  Airplanes would also be unrealistic because air-travel around New York City is extremely restricted, plus there's really not enough area to ''need'' air-travel.
::{{Gripe}} Tanks and airplanes are more realistic than being released from custody hours after being arrested for mass murder / terrorism. If ommisions are to be made for the sake of realism then there must be a level of consistency.  
::{{Gripe}} Tanks and airplanes are more realistic than being released from custody hours after being arrested for mass murder / terrorism. If omissions are to be made for the sake of realism then there must be a level of consistency.  


{{Gripe}}There are no car mods or even simply choosing your paint color.
{{Gripe}}There are no car mods or even simply choosing your paint color.
Line 204: Line 213:
{{Gripe}}There are fewer cars in the game compared to San Andreas, and no fixed-wing aircraft available to the player.  Even though the city is smaller than [[GTA San Andreas]], the designers of the game shouldn't have lost more stuff than they put in, that includes Vehicles and Planes. Just a general mistake on behalf of rockstar
{{Gripe}}There are fewer cars in the game compared to San Andreas, and no fixed-wing aircraft available to the player.  Even though the city is smaller than [[GTA San Andreas]], the designers of the game shouldn't have lost more stuff than they put in, that includes Vehicles and Planes. Just a general mistake on behalf of rockstar
:{{Rebut}}No there are more cars in GTA IV then in San Andreas. More choices.
:{{Rebut}}No there are more cars in GTA IV then in San Andreas. More choices.
::{{Gripe}}The variety of vehicles is greatly reduced. This limits the players experience and hurts the overall playability of the free roam game.


{{Gripe}}How the Voodoo was changed.
{{Gripe}}How the Voodoo was changed.
Line 220: Line 230:
{{Gripe}}Airbags do not deploy on any vehicles when slammed head-on at high speeds.
{{Gripe}}Airbags do not deploy on any vehicles when slammed head-on at high speeds.
:{{Rebut}}That just brings out the fun of the new physics engine, seeing Niko fly out of the car. Plus I don't really think that it really has to be this realistic. It would just ruin the fact that this is a GAME.
:{{Rebut}}That just brings out the fun of the new physics engine, seeing Niko fly out of the car. Plus I don't really think that it really has to be this realistic. It would just ruin the fact that this is a GAME.
::{{Gripe}}Another area where realism is affected. If realism is to be the justification for  limiting the players experience then anything unrealistic becomes a criticism of the game.


{{Gripe}}You can't attach trailers in the back of your truck like in [[GTA San Andreas]].
{{Gripe}}You can't attach trailers in the back of your truck like in [[GTA San Andreas]].
:{{Rebut}}What would you do exactly with a trailer on the back of your truck?
:{{Rebut}}What would you do exactly with a trailer on the back of your truck?
::{{Gripe}}Gas Tank trailers, Containers, Car Transporters, etc.
::{{Gripe}}Gas Tank trailers, Containers, Car Transporters, etc.
:::{{Gripe}}Limits the scope of possibilities in the free roam game. Shortens the lifespan of the game. The RS Haul Missions in SA could provide hours of game play on their own.


{{Gripe}}Brucie's helicopter is useless. It would have been better if you could fly his helicopter yourself.
{{Gripe}}Brucie's helicopter is useless. It would have been better if you could fly his helicopter yourself.
Line 264: Line 276:
{{Gripe}}Roofs from vehicles doesn't get crushed when you roll over. There aren't any roll bars from any cars.
{{Gripe}}Roofs from vehicles doesn't get crushed when you roll over. There aren't any roll bars from any cars.
:{{Rebut}}Theres a roll cage in the Sultan RS. Also, the roof of a car is supposed to be a very protective part of a car.
:{{Rebut}}Theres a roll cage in the Sultan RS. Also, the roof of a car is supposed to be a very protective part of a car.
::{{Gripe}}But all other cars don't even have rollbars and they're not supposed to stay intact even after a hard landing.
::{{Gripe}}But all other cars don't even have roll bars and they're not supposed to stay intact even after a hard landing.


{{Gripe}}The [[Dozer]] is gone, regardless on going into any construction sites.
{{Gripe}}The [[Dozer]] is gone, regardless on going into any construction sites.
Line 332: Line 344:
:::{{Rebut}}Play QUB3D
:::{{Rebut}}Play QUB3D
::::{{Gripe}}I'd rather play Duality, Go Go Space Monkey, and They Crawled from Uranus from [[GTA San Andreas]], rather than just one arcade game that [[Rockstar Games]] totally ruined it.
::::{{Gripe}}I'd rather play Duality, Go Go Space Monkey, and They Crawled from Uranus from [[GTA San Andreas]], rather than just one arcade game that [[Rockstar Games]] totally ruined it.
:::::{{Gripe}}The amount of "random games" was substantially reduced. This affects realism, in terms of the player being able to interact with the city and the longevity, with yet another 5 or 6 sources of amusement the game doesn't have.


{{Gripe}}There are only 3 unique [[Clothing]] stores in the game.
{{Gripe}}There are only 3 unique [[Clothing]] stores in the game.
Line 402: Line 415:
{{Gripe}}Considering how Rockstar Games put alot of good well known songs on the radio in both GTA Vice City and San Andreas (as well as having the Scarface soundtrack in GTA III), I was surprised and dissappointed to find out that GTA IV's soundtrack is mostly made up of unknown artists (granted, there are several big name artists but, hardly any compared to previous games) and completely fails to reflect popular music of the current decade, in my opinion. However, the parodys of the war on terror, internet, movies etc on the radio do reflect the decade well.
{{Gripe}}Considering how Rockstar Games put alot of good well known songs on the radio in both GTA Vice City and San Andreas (as well as having the Scarface soundtrack in GTA III), I was surprised and dissappointed to find out that GTA IV's soundtrack is mostly made up of unknown artists (granted, there are several big name artists but, hardly any compared to previous games) and completely fails to reflect popular music of the current decade, in my opinion. However, the parodys of the war on terror, internet, movies etc on the radio do reflect the decade well.
:{{Rebut}}Listen to an ipod or MP3.
:{{Rebut}}Listen to an ipod or MP3.
{{Gripe}}The city is grossly under populated. Go to Star Junction at 9pm on a Friday Night and it is deserted. 5pm on a Friday, there is some traffic, but for what it is supposed to be it just falls short again. There are more peds behind the flats in Northwood than in Star Junction. The report that Rockstar modeled the traffic on NYC is pure garbage. Living breathing city....not even close.


===Characters===
===Characters===
Line 436: Line 451:
{{Gripe}} Dimitri & Bulgarin make no attempt to attack or engage the Bellic Cousins outside of a mission. Previous games featured "no-go" areas or random attacks in accordance with the storyline. The fact that the Russian mob are central to the story, but unsighted in the open world portion of the game again hurts the believability of the story.
{{Gripe}} Dimitri & Bulgarin make no attempt to attack or engage the Bellic Cousins outside of a mission. Previous games featured "no-go" areas or random attacks in accordance with the storyline. The fact that the Russian mob are central to the story, but unsighted in the open world portion of the game again hurts the believability of the story.
:{{Rebut}}Technically the story is paused while not on a mission
:{{Rebut}}Technically the story is paused while not on a mission
::{{Gripe}} Yeah, seems as if the "story" is paused when Niko isn't on a mission. So much for a living breathing city, the city is nearly completely insulated from anything that happens in the story. Once again this badly affects the realism, at times the only thing that makes IV an open world game is the Burger Shot. Everything else is basically scripted i.e freinds activities, Stevie's missions, races. The only thing open world about IV is that you can go anywhere, you certainly can't do anything.


{{Gripe}} According to the police database website, Bulgarin is dead. This is just a stupid idea from Rockstar, because I'm betting that every person here wants to kill him.
{{Gripe}} According to the police database website, Bulgarin is dead. This is just a stupid idea from Rockstar, because I'm betting that every person here wants to kill him.
Anonymous user
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.